Book Club Update: Nonfiction Spree

Book club commuter… my new role! Previously, I lived in the same town as most of our book club members. Now I’m 45 minutes away — a totally worthwhile drive to spend time with friends, discussing books. But still: a change. And most recently, I got to host, so the good people of book club made the long trek south.

In recent months, another interesting shift: it’s been all about the nonfiction. And I love the nonfiction.

Here’s how it’s gone…

 

The Indifferent Stars Above: The Harrowing Saga of a Donner Party Bride by Daniel James Brown

Discussibility Score: 4

Because: While we didn’t love the book (and I thought at least two of us would love the book — me because of my adoration of Brown’s The Boys in the Boat and my fondness for true tragedy, and my good friend because of her ghoulish tastes), we had a solid discussion of what we liked and didn’t. And how the writing and the structure of the book led us to those conclusions. I expected to feel a little bit more than I did, but I can’t fault an author for restraint, especially when writing about cannibalism.

 

Nomadland: Surviving America in the Twenty-First Century by Jessica Bruder

Discussibility Score: 3

Because: Our book club loves discussing sociological trends, so this book opened up a good line of conversation about what’s going on with the middle class and the former middle class. And also about alternate lifestyles (people living in campers and traveling to seasonal jobs) due to reduced economic circumstances.

 

Prairie Fires: The American Dreams of Laura Ingalls Wilder by Caroline Fraser

Discussibility Score: 5

Because: We actually discussed the book for more than an hour. And we were only discussing the first half of the book! (We split it into two meetings, because the thing is 600+ pages long.) We were fascinated by the way Laura’s early years make up so little of this biography. And how itinerant she was as a young adult. We’d just gotten to the part where Laura’s relationship with her daughter was getting kind of weird, to our minds. And now we can’t wait to read the rest. (Thanks to Bybee for the rave review on this one, which strongly influenced our decision to read it.)

 

So… for our next book club: more Laura Ingalls Wilder biography reading, as we finish the book. And for me… a real-life trek across the prairie to book club.

by

Reader, librarian, & happy little geek

Leave a Reply